Hello, I am starting this due to the recent population drop and potential abandonment of this server.
When this server first opened (I found it like 2 weeks after launch) everything was pretty damn cool, you could level easily enough, there were tons of people of all level ranges looking for parties, and MVP COMPETITION, because you could solo them, there was at least five people trying to get an mvp, not just being forced to eden board.
I'll be listing a couple of issues I feel led to this situation of players being way to frustrated with the server and the admins who run it.
Just to get it out of the way, PvP, this server did a pretty good job not allowing vellum/woe gear to be available for two main reasons, one being that they seem pretty OP, and two the server was at a 200 population count, maybe 100 active actual players and making these items obtainable so early on could have had a horrible outcome for new players looking to WoE only to find that the guilds holding the castles are hoarding the items and have +12 weapons by now.
PvP is not very appealing to players who do not know how to obtain end game gear, either by themselves or the other alternative in this server, try to find a five man party, then try to somehow have synergy and communication between these five people, struggle to take down a beelz, for a 50% drop rate for shoes that has a chance to land on someone who will probably never want to mvp party again now that they have the item they want. There is no need to try to make pvp appealing, players who want to 1 v 1 will want to play regardless of reward, and BG already has rewards in the form of glorious items. One of the main reasons I have noticed people don't want to pvp is out of embarrassment, They don't want to stain their good name of their super cool RK "Clit Destroyer" by running in to pvp with shit tier items only to find out they aren't as good as they thought.
That is really all I have to say about PvP, besides the whole WoE timer shit, I had fun in WoE, and in the like two games of BG I got to play
PvP develops after a player feels comfortable enough with their items and disposables consumables that they are willing to go into pvp and test their metal vs others.
Instead of focusing on making MvPs unsoloable I believe the admins should be focusing on things they actually didn't fuck up on. Such as skill and item balancing. Ranger Unlimit nerf was one of the greatest things I have ever heard, it made Ranger's dps less retarded, white wing custom changes, fuck yeah gives you more of a reason to refine the shoes and mant instead of just enchanting purposes. Maybe not just focus on nerfing shit but buffing shit as well, I'm not to familiar with the GX situation but I've seen a lot of pissed people and hmmm Earth strain doing more damage than asura, to the point that asura can be tanked by anything wearing a raydric? that doesnt seem right to me, although I say that I know the admin team has created a make shift way to deal with the outrageous WL DPS. Anyway, focusing on skill balance and item balance should take way more priority over soloing mvps, which isn't even a problem, I'm sure it will impact the economy but nothing can be worse than a single player with 1bil because pay2win. I haven't even seen a single valk armor or variants in vend.
PvM, what the fuck happened. A lot of people who are looking for a renewal server are looking for a place with active players, a "balanced" economy, and leveling that doesn't start to stagnate after you reach 150+. I'm sure most players who actually read this remember the whole Stoneskin shit epidemic which threatened a server wide rage quit and the custom mvp stats and skill changes aren't helping.
Also, the number of solo players largely out numbers the amount of players who join a server in a group, and even then within a group of players there are bound to be times where they can not all play together due to a plethora of reasons. When new players join assuming this will be like any other server they have played before, only to find a Kaupe Beelz and a Vesper with dispell and EQ, rage quits are always imminent. MY SUGGESTION, just revert shit back to the way they used to be, this server is going to end up just being a server with a lot of custom changes that an admin dreamed would attract players.
If you bring back the solo play aspect of RO which most people actually DO like, and the admins are willing to drop their stubborn attitude about what a server should be like, then maybe this server will start to grow once more. RO is a dead game, only true fans still play it and no one wants the game to be any harder and time consuming than it already is. With that in mind realize that the larger half of the RO population is made up of 20+ year olds, adults with very little time to play. Personally I can barley find time to play, not because I'm THAT busy but because there is nothing to fucking do on this server, sure farming shit is an important aspect but for what? There is literally no items worth buying in vend aside from leika coins (pay2win). If you want an active community this server has to once again become appealing to SINGLE PLAYERS because not everyone has a group to party with you have left the server in a state of constant mid game, since end game gear is only obtainable by the few guilds this server has (had) and even then, they are obviously just going to share amongst each other, maybe vend a pair of variants for 200mil, oh wait Gio bought them, guess its time to wait another 5 weeks.
Bottom line is, this server isn't very appealing since everything is party oriented, renewal broke that a long time ago, no going back now.